Hilltop Mexican Restaurant

4.6 (137 reviews )
$$
Mexican restaurant
Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery
+(11)

About Hilltop Mexican Restaurant

Hilltop Mexican Restaurant, nestled in Fennimore, WI, is a hidden gem offering authentic Mexican cuisine that truly impresses. Known for its hearty taco salads, velvety chocolate cake, and mouth-watering al pastor, the restaurant delivers flavors that rival those of top urban eateries. Diners rave about the awesome fajitas and homemade salsas, which elevate every dish. The friendly service adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for gatherings or a cozy date night. With great prices and a chill vibe, Hilltop is worth the trip for anyone seeking a genuine taste of Mexico in small-town America.

Reviews (137) 4.6

  • Luz Burkard
    Jul 22,2025

    The Taco salad was hearty and fresh. They served us velvety chocolate cake for our anniversary. Great service!

  • The Hat Man
    Jul 22,2025

    What a fantastic little spot off the beaten track in small town Wisconsin. Great authentic Mexican food which rivals some of the finest places I've had in big urban areas. The al pastor was out of this world delicious with a great depth of flavor

  • Mike Olsen
    Jul 22,2025

    Stopped on for dinner 23 Feb. Food was delicious. Language barrier was a huge issue but worked through it. Queso needs the be thinned. Too thick for my liking.

  • Brad “Solarman” Temple
    Jul 22,2025

    This place has amazing food. The Menuedo and Lengua tacos! Perfect!

  • Southern star
    Jul 22,2025

    Awesome fajitas and amazing margaritas!!! super chill spot with pool table an outdoor patio. Wonderful experience

  • Debbie
    Jul 22,2025

    I've eaten a lot of Mexican food all over the country and even Mexico. Why this restaurant isn't constantly packed is beyond me. The food was absolutely amazing. And it is amazingly priced. The Hilltop is well worth driving out of your way to enjoy delicious, authentic Mexican food!

  • Kyle Smietanski
    Jul 22,2025

    This is real Mexican food, not Tex Mex. I tried the torta which was amazing! Service was fast and friendly. The bartender/owner brought out a few of his home-made salsas/hot sauces after talking to me about my love of spicey things. They were all very tasty. The flavors of my meal and the hot sauces are something you don't get in an American style Mexican restaurant. I will definitely stop by if I'm in the area again.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are some popular dishes at Hilltop Mexican Restaurant?

    Customers rave about the al pastor tacos, fajitas, and tortas, along with their hearty taco salad and delicious margaritas.

  • Do I need to make a reservation, or can I walk in?

    Hilltop Mexican Restaurant accepts reservations, but walk-ins are also welcome, making it convenient for both planned visits and spontaneous outings.

  • What dining options are available at the restaurant?

    You can enjoy dine-in, takeout, or delivery options, so you can choose what suits you best!

  • What is the atmosphere like, and when is the best time to visit?

    The restaurant has a cozy and casual vibe, perfect for families or groups. It's a nice spot to visit for lunch or dinner, especially if you enjoy sports on TV!

  • Is there parking available and what payment methods do you accept?

    Yes, there is free parking available both in the lot and on the street. They accept credit and debit cards for your convenience.

Nearby Mexican restaurants

Mexican restaurant
Cantina Margaritas Mexican Grill - Stanley

117 N Broadway St, Stanley, WI 54768, United States

Mexican restaurant
Mexico Grill & Bar

108 E Union St, Waupaca, WI 54981, United States

Mexican restaurant
Fiesta Cantina Authentic Mexican Food

1705 Plaza Dr, Menomonie, WI 54751, United States

Mexican restaurant
Taqueria La Estrella 2

1170 W Main St, Whitewater, WI 53190, United States

Mexican restaurant
Las Fajitas

10114 W Greenfield Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53214, United States

Mexican restaurant
Los Hernandez

Corner of Fair Street and Millston Avenue, 807 N Main St, Lodi, WI 53555, United States

Mexican restaurant
Super Street Tacos La Crosse

1800 State St, La Crosse, WI 54601, United States

Mexican restaurant
Cozumel

1111 Westowne Dr, Neenah, WI 54956, United States

Mexican restaurant
Casa Luna Mexican Grill

111 S Main St, Lodi, WI 53555, United States

Mexican restaurant
Taqueria El Jalapeño

1318 S Midvale Blvd, Madison, WI 53711, United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page